Streaming history only displaying correctly while song is playing

When I click on these songs under “Currently Playing” the stats display correctly (first streamed June 2023), but when I click on them under “Recently Played” or search for them to look at my stats, it only shows my stats since August 20, 2024, despite still having “lifetime” stats selected. The leaderboards for these songs also appear drastically different depending on whether I click on the song under “Currently Playing” or elsewhere.